DSC-RX100M3
ƒ/5.6
12.35 mm
1/80
125

Happy 4/20… to the moon!
Fifty years ago, at 7:23pm PST, Apollo 16 touched down on the moon. To celebrate this occasion, I will share one of my treasured artifacts from the mission — the moon rock manifest used by Duke and Young to tally the weight of the samples gathered over three days on the lunar surface and three Rover rides around town (EVA 1-3). The page is smudged with lunar dust from their gloves as they weighed each precious rock and bags of regolith dust on a pound-scale adjusted for 1/6 gravity.

They had a target total weight budget, which they exceeded, and they had to get permission from mission control to retain the Apollo-record-setting-haul of 213 lbs. They also had a load balancing challenge of where to place each sample collection bag across four locations, with weight limits on each. so as to not shift the center of gravity of the lunar module ascent stage for launch (see the COLLECTION BAG STOWAGE exercise at the center of the page; each number there is the bag number, with the weight of each bag noted above; it all adds up within the limits, barely). Essential arithmetic for the mission!

The reverse side of the checklist, below, entitled “CABIN PREP.-EVA 1,” was used to prepare for the first Moon walk. LM Pilot Duke made sure that everything needed to sustain life was checked off before stepping out of the Lunar Module to explore the Moon, including Buddy Secondary Life Support Systems (BSLSS), cameras, film, rock collection bags, sun compass, maps, and checklists, as well as the very first roll of duct tape brought to the lunar surface! I’ll add details on that in the comments below.

There are 16 checkmarks and other notations written by Moonwalker Duke while on the Moon’s surface. The dark stains on both sides of the checklist are particles of lunar dust.

I started my space collecting with a focus on Apollo 16, and this rock manifest is quite rare (only 3 exist). In the comments below, I’ll include the NASA transcript from the Lunar Module to Mission Control as they processed each of the three moon rock hauls. I was trying to find video of the unloading process but have not found it for Apollo 16 yet.

Each rock has detailed analysis. For example, here is the writeup on the first 14-lb rock, and an overview of the Apollo 16 collection.

An image of this page is also on the NASA server. And the opinion of The opinion of SpaceRelics: “During the past seven years, I have been privileged to catalog and appraise tens of thousands of flown and unflown American space artifacts from virtually every mission. However, in all that time, this particular artifact has stood out in my mind as potentially one of the most significant. This item represents one of the most important original source documents of the space program, and indeed the entire pantheon of human exploration.”

An artifact from the Future Ventures’ 🚀 Space Collection.

2 responses to “The Apollo 16 Moon Rock Manifest, Smudged with Moon Dust”

  1. With Charlie Duke:Flip side:Prior to Apollo 16, the crews had a roll of duct tape in the LM but didn’t take it outside. A preflight, handwritten addition to page 2-1 of this flown Apollo 16 LM Lunar Surface Checklist adds a 25-foot roll of tape (25’ TAPE) to the contents of the Equipment Transfer Bag (ETB) during the EVA-1 Prep. Other handwritten changes on the page were made on the Moon by Charlie Duke after the delayed landing forced revisions of plans. The roll of tape stayed in the ETB. Consequently, Duke and Young always had a roll of tape with them, transferring it back and forth between the cabin and the surface in the ETB. The Apollo 17 crew did the same.

    Letter from LMP Charlie Duke:Lunar scale:NASA Transcript Post EVA 1: http://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a16/a16.eva1post.html
    127:10:31 Duke: Okay, Ed we’re on the Lunar Surface Checklist, page 3-4. Over.
    127:10:36 England: Okay, Charlie. We copy that.
    [Long Comm Break – jump to minute 3:37 for audio: http://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a16/a16a1271031.mp3]
    [Since getting back in the cabin, they have been using the Prep & Post Cards. Now, they have gotten out the Surface Checklist and have started the procedures at the top of Surface 3-4.]
    127:14:06 Duke: Okay, Houston. SCB number 5 is in sample containment bag (that is, cover bag) number 5, and it weighs 14 (terrestrial) pounds.
    [Sample Containment Bags were flown on the J missions to help reduce the amount of dust in the cabin. The Sample Collection Bags were put inside the Containment Bags. Photos of containment bags in the National Air & Space collection courtesy Allan Needell. After weighing the bag, John and Charlie record the weight on page 2-2 of the LM Lunar Surface Checklist.]
    127:14:17 England: Okay. We copy that. SCB bag (5) in bag 5, and it weighs 14 pounds.
    127:14:28 Young: Of which at least 10 pounds (4.5 kg) must be the SCB. (Tony chuckles)
    [John is joking that much of the weight must be the dust on the SCB. As indicated in Table 6 in Judy Allton’s Catalog of Apollo Lunar Surface Geological Sampling Tools and Containers, SCB-5 weighs 565 grams (1.2 pounds) empty.]
    [The scale they are using to weigh the sample containers is shown in Figure 58 from Judy’s Tool Book. It is calibrated to give readings in terrestrial pounds.]
    127:14:32 England: Oh, you collected a lot of rocks out there.
    127:14:44 Duke: That was only one rock, and that was a grab sample that I got (at about 125:08:40) about 30 meters in front of the LM. Over.
    127:14:51 England: Right. That’s right. (Pause)
    [This sample is 60015, a 5.6 kg piece of glass coated rock. The combined weight of the SCB and the sample is 6.1 kg or 13.5 pounds. Because the scale is marked in 5-pound increments, this weight is indistinguishable from the 14 pounds Charlie read out to Houston. Sample 60015 is a cataclastic anorthosite (cataclastic means that the rock has been deformed under pressure. On Earth, cataclastic rocks are ususally associated with fault zones. In this case, impact stresses are the likely cause. All surfaces except the bottom are thickly coated with glass. The overall cosmic ray exposure age of the rock is about 2 million years, suggesting that the rock was ejected in the South Ray impact. The glass coatings have a micrometeorite-exposure age of about 100,000 years, suggesting that, for most of the time since ejection, only the bottom surface was been exposed. Micrometeorite impacts cleaned much of the glass off that surface before the rock turned over – presumably by a small, local impact – about 100,000 years ago.]
    127:14:55 Duke: Okay. SRC number 1 weighs 42 (terrestrial) pounds.
    127:15:01 England: Okay. We copy.
    127:15:07 Duke: And that’s all the rocks we got.
    127:15:11 England: Okay. (Long Pause)
    [The empty SRC weighs 6.6 kilograms or 14.5 pounds.]
    127:15:47 England: Okay. I don’t know how factual it is, but I remember getting a note the last week before launch that you had your rock control weight up to 215 pounds. (Pause)
    127:16:01 Young: Okay, Tony. We’ll get 215 pounds of rock.
    127:16:04 England: I bet you will.
    127:16:05 Young: How much have we got now?
    127:16:10 England: Oh, you have 56 pounds you called back, including the weight of the SRC, which is about 12 pounds. So that would make it about 44 pounds. (Pause) I bet the "Muley Special" down there will double your weight.
    127:16:40 Young: I’m sure it will. (Joking) It gave Charlie a hernia. (Long Pause)
    [Big Muley is sample 61016 ( 175k ) and weighs 11.7 kg or 25.7 terrestrial pounds. Its lunar weight is 4.3 pounds.]
    [When Charlie collected the rock at 124:08:29, he immediately associated it with Bill Muehlberger when he said, "If I fall into Plum Crater getting this rock, Muehlberger has had it." Later, when he was back at the LM at 125:24:09 during the closeout, he referred to the sample in the following way: "And I got a great big rock: a muley." A little while later, at 125:24:53, he referred to it as "that rock we picked up (next to the Rover at Station 1), the big – the muley…". In 1996, I asked Tony if, prior to the mission, Bill Muehlberger was known as "Muley" and, if not, whether the double meaning of "Muley" – referring to Muehlberger and to the size of the rock – was obvious at the time.]
    [England, from a 1996 letter – "I never heard anyone call Bill M. ‘Muley’, but I was aware that it referred to him. Charlie played with words a lot so he probably invented the association with the rock on the spot. We would have all understood it. Bill is not only big, but he is a little stubborn. The ‘Muley’ played on his name, his size, and, just a little, on his being stubborn. Of course, I’d never say that when I was within Bill’s reach."]
    [Muehlberger, from a 1996 letter – "My nickname in college was ‘Mully’ – short version of Mull-(as it is pronounced)-berger. There were times when ‘Mule-y’ was also used! So, with Lee Silver and Dallas Peck, both part of my team, always around and also college friends using that nickname, it became my nickname for all. I guess it was a short step for the crew to bless the largest rock – I was 210 lbs and 6’1 – ‘Big Muley’."]
    [Readers should also note that when Ed Mitchell serves as CapCom after EVA-2, he refers to the rock as "Mully" at 151:09:14, a clear indication that he knows it was named for Bill Muehlberger.]
    127:17:09 England: Okay, and that SCB-5 we’d just like you to stow behind the engine cover, if you can still get to it behind the suits there. We can’t give you a permanent location, because we don’t have the c.g. (center of gravity) yet, without the rest of the rocks.
    127:17:24 Young: Understand. It doesn’t make much difference right now.

    NASA Transcript POST EVA-2: http://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a16/a16.eva2post.html

    151:07:57 Duke: Houston, Orion.
    151:08:02 Mitchell: Go ahead, Charlie.
    151:08:06 Duke: Okay, Ed. I got some (sample container) weights for you (as per Surface 5-4). You ready to copy?
    151:08:09 Mitchell: Stand by one.
    [ After weighing the sample containers, John and Charlie record the weights on page 2-2 of the LM Lunar Surface Checklist. and are now ready to read up the numbers.]
    151:08:10 Duke: The SRC number 2…(Stops to listen) Okay. (Pause)
    151:08:18 Mitchell: Go ahead.
    151:08:23 Duke: Okay, the SRC number 2 weighs 41 pounds (18.6 kg). SCB-3, which is in sample containment bag number 3, weighs 30 pounds (13.6 kg). SCB-1, which is in sample containment bag number 4, weighs 26 pounds (11.8 kg). Over.
    [Sample Containment Bags were flown on the J missions to help reduce the amount of dust in the cabin. The Sample Collection Bags were put inside the Containment Bags. Photos of containment bags in the National Air & Space collection courtesy Allan Needell.]
    [The empty Sample Return Container (SRC or rock box) weighs 14.7 pounds (6.7 kg) and the empty Sample Collection Bags (SCBs) weigh about 1.7 pounds (0.8 kg) each.]
    151:08:46 Mitchell: Okay, SRC 2 is 41 pounds. SCB number 3, which is the containment bag 3, is 30 pounds. SCB number 1, which is in containment bag 4, is 26 pounds.
    151:09:01 Young: That’s Charlie’s. (Pause)
    151:09:14 Mitchell: Keep going like that, you may have to throw away "Mully".
    [Readers should note that Ed pronounces the rock name as "Mull-y", rather than Charlie’s "Mule-y", a clear indication that he knows it’s been named for Geology P.I. Bill Muehlberger (pronounced "mull-ber-ger"). See the discussion following 127:16:40.]
    151:09:24 Young: (Big Muley) isn’t on board yet.

    NASA Transcript POST EVA-3: http://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a16/a16.eva3post.html
    171:39:32 Duke: Yeah, I don’t think it’s necessary to put that back in the sack. All they’re doing it for is weight. You don’t have to (garbled). "Unstow scale, weigh Buddy SLSS/rock bag, and collection bags." Okay, here we go with the… First, the big rock (garbled). (Pause)
    [ They are now weighing the sample containers. They will record the weights on page 2-2 of the LM Lunar Surface Checklist and will read them up to Tony after they finish.]
    171:40:11 Duke: 65 pounds max, supposed to be. (Correcting himself) 35 (terrestrial pounds maximum). (Long Pause)
    171:40:30 Duke: John. Yeah, number 7. (Pause)
    171:40:45 Duke: We can get one rock in there, I think. (Pause)
    171:40:56 Duke: Yeah? One that’s been in the shade. Get that one in there, that one will go in, too. (Pause)
    171:41:11 Duke: That one will go. Try it now. That’s all that’s in there? (Pause)
    171:41:32 Duke: Baby rocks. Well, let’s call it 40, and see what they say. They’ll let us go with that, I’ll bet you. Buddy SLSS bag is 40 (pounds). Bag 7, (garbled). Huh?
    [Comm Break]
    171:43:23 Duke: Houston, Orion. Over.
    171:43:25 England: Go ahead, Charlie.
    171:43:30 Duke: Okay. We’ve got some weights for you, if you’re ready to copy.
    171:43:33 England: All set.
    171:43:37 Duke: Okay. The BSLSS rock bag, the big rocks, will weigh 40 pounds; bag 7, SCB number 7, is 33; SCB number 4 is 25; SCB number 6 is 20. I get a total out of that of about 118 (pounds). Over. (Pause)
    171:44:01 England: Okay, we concur.
    [Comm Break]
    171:45:06 England: Okay. We’re working those numbers over here. (Pause)
    171:45:20 Duke: Okay, Tony, we’ve got a weight-saver for you. The ISA only weighs 10 (pounds).
    [The maximum allowable weight on the ISA is 18 pounds.]
    171:45:26 England: Okay. ISA weighs 10.
    171:45:29 Duke: Actually, it weighs 8 pounds.
    171:45:31 England: Okay, 8.
    171:45:33 Duke: Make that 8.
    [Long Comm Break]
    MP3 Audio Clip ( 10 min 00 sec )
    This clip begins with a 51 second interval with no comm.
    171:49:52 England: Hey, fellows, you have 245 pounds of rocks. (Pause) That’s not including the weights of the SRCs.
    171:50:05 Young: Okay, has some got to go back?
    171:50:09 England: No, I think we’re going to be able to find a way. You got an in-plane launch, so things look pretty good. But we’re working it here. 171:50:20 Slayton: (Joking) Probably have to throw that big one away, John.
    171:50:22 Young: Okay, we’re getting… We’re getting to the point where we got to know… (Listens to Deke) Say again?
    171:50:29 Slayton: We’ll probably have to throw away that big one.
    171:50:39 Young: Okay. Well, we don’t want to throw away any that don’t need to be throwed away. That’s for sure. (Pause) I tell you, there’s a couple more tons (of rocks) up here we missed.
    171:51:02 England: Say again, John.
    171:51:07 Young: I say, there’s a couple of tons up here that we didn’t pick up.
    [Long Comm Break]
    [They are over the planned limit for samples and, in principle, would be cutting into propellant margins if they kept them all. As Tony mentions, however, the Command Module orbit is perfectly lined up so that John and Charlie wouldn’t have to apply any lateral thrust to achieve the rendezvous. Nonetheless, the fact that Houston is taking a long time to make a decision about the over-limit samples is indicative of the pragmatic conservatism that motivated most operational decisions in Apollo.]
    171:56:14 Young: Houston, we’re about to the point (where) we’re (garbled) the jettison bag.
    171:56:19 England: I’m sorry, Charlie… John, say again?
    171:56:25 Young: Roger. We’re ready to tie up the jett bag.
    171:56:28 England: Okay. We’re still trying to get a decision on these rocks down here, if you could hold on one.
    171:56:38 Young: Don’t want to miss the launch. (Pause) I’m just kidding, Tony. Take as long as you need to, to get it right. I know how that is. (Pause)
    171:57:08 Duke: Tony, if it helps you out, this morning we jettisoned the CWG (Constant Wear Garment)s, the LCGs, all of the sleep restraints, everything like that. That was a pretty big bag.
    171:57:20 England: Okay.
    [Long Comm Break]
    MP3 Audio Clip ( 13 min 19 sec )
    This clip begins with a 7 min 10 second interval with no comm.
    172:05:59 England: Okay, Orion. We’re go with the rocks you’ve got.
    172:06:07 Young: Outstanding. Thank you very much.

  2. And i just purchased the rock scoop Duke used on Apollo 16Charlie Duke Holding the Apollo 16 Lunar Scoop

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *