NIKON D70
ƒ/4
18 mm
1/60

…the true Armstrong hero.

At Kelly’s house, I had the chance to ask him a question about the first landing on the moon that provoked a response that seemed poignant and awe-inspiring.

I asked him, of all of the systems and stages of the mission, which did he worry about the most? He had spoken about the frequently failing autopilot… the reliance on a global network of astronomers to spot solar flares in time to get the warning out… the onboard computers being less powerful than a Furby…

No, none of those. He dove into a detailed description of the hypergolic fuel mixing system for the lunar module. Rather than an ignition system, they had two substances that would ignite upon contact. Instead of electric valves, he wished he had a big simple mechanical lever to open the valves. He kept using his hands to show how easy a big lever could be.

That seemed a bit odd to me at first. So, I asked if he gave that answer because it really was the most likely point of failure, or because it symbolizes a vivid nightmare – having completed the moon mission, pushing the button… and the engines just wont start.

He responded that he had nightmares about that for two years prior to the launch.

It’s a setup for a sequence of tough decisions. What would you do? Go for a long walk? Spend your remaining moments on the radio with loved ones? Have one volunteer try to hotwire it from outside…. Ask Buzz for his air…?

And then, during the Apollo 11 mission, guess what happened? The critical ascent switch broke! Buzz Aldrin later wrote: “A few hours earlier, after we returned to the LM interior once completing the first lunar moon walk, I noticed that the ascent engine arming breaker push/pull switch was broken. Apparently during movement wearing our large space suit ‘backpacks,’ either Neil or I bumped into this panel and broke off that particular switch. This switch was the direct means of arming our Ascent Stage engine which would allow us to leave the lunar surface. Mission Control verified that the switch was open, meaning that the engine was currently unarmed. If we could not get the engine armed, we would be stranded on the Moon. They advised us to leave the switch in the open position until the timeline called for it to be engaged. I started to think of ways to activate the switch if pushing it by hand failed. As it turned out, the very pen I used to record these notes was the perfect tool to engage this circuit breaker.”

And a revelation from one Neil Armstrong’s last, and rare interviews that I discovered while researching the Eagle construction log — prior to launch, he thought there was only a 50% chance of successfully landing on the moon, but that they should go for it.

Happy birthday, hero of humanity.

14 responses to “Happy Birthday Neil Armstrong”

  1. The subject of his worry… and schematic of that complex nest of valves…
    Lunar Module Ascent Engine Valve Package Assembly vpa_schematic

    walking on the moon… Those iconic boot prints captured before launch…
    Neil Armstrong's Moon Boot Prints

    His bacon-rich menu…
    Apollo 11 Menu for Neil Armstrong

    Photos from the X-15 days, and harrowing adventures bouncing off the atmosphere over LA…
    Neil Armstrong — Test Pilot

    HIs lunar globe
    Neil Armstrong’s Moon

    and the engineering notes for Eagle… with SO many open issues on the electrical systems…
    How the Eagle Landed — the Grumman Construction Log

    and a piece of the Eagle spacecraft brought back to Earth, perhaps the only piece other than the lunar sample return…
    A Rare Piece of the Apollo 11 Lunar Module Eagle

  2. interesting reporting

  3. Thank you for this. I’ve read the Fischer Space Pen blurb about this incident and it is nice to "hear" Armstrong confirm it. Very interesting that he admitted to having nightmares about that scenario.

  4. I will never, ever, ever forget that day – in school at age 9, having to explain to the headmaster what all the bits on the spacecraft did, watching a live broadcast of a guy walking on another world.

    Time we went back.

  5. Oh we will. For the first time in my life, I have confidence of that.

  6. It wouldn’t surprise me at all if you find your way onto the 2nd or 3rd post-Apollo moonshot … I get the impression it’s what your whole life has been leading to. Like Reid Malenfent, but without the destruction of the universe via vacuum decay!

  7. [http://www.flickr.com/photos/philatkin] — That is my dream… but it does not have to be one of the early missions. Unlike Apollo, there is no rush. These missions will not require the training or career dedication or luck of catching the right mission assignment before the program ends; rather, the longer we wait, the cheaper and safer it should be, hopefully falling into the comfort zone for many of us.

    Here is another great Armstrong story I discovered in a Grumman interview that came out just before Armstrong’s passing. It sheds some light on those famous first words on the moon. Nobody knew what Neil was going to say in advance, and Neil insists that it was not written down or rehearsed. He may have been inspired by the moment:

    "The famous first words spoken by Neil Armstrong as he descended the LEM ladder toward the lunar surface on July 16, 1969, had a dual meaning. As he jumped onto the lunar surface Armstrong said, "That’s one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind." He jumped! This was because the LEM had landed more softly than expected, and the legs did not crumple as much as expected… If the expected impact force had occurred, the last rung of the descent ladder, attached to the landing leg, would be located close to the surface. It was not, so Armstrong had to leap to the ground from a much higher level than planned."

    The Lunar Module has an ingenious single-use shock absorber made of crushable aluminum honeycomb that I got from the LM restoration lead at Grumman Bethpage:

    Apollo Lunar Module Shock Absorber

    This honeycomb was designed to take an impact of 10 ft. per second, but none of the landings were more than 4 fps, so they did not crush very far, and the final step off the LM ladder was thus a longer step.

    So just prior to the broadcast of that famous first step, Neil jumped down and then tested whether he could get back up to the first rung of the ladder from the landing pad (he was also careful to not step off the pad and touch the lunar surface before the cameras were rolling). From the Apollo 11 transcript:

    109:22:48 McCandless: Okay. Neil, we can see you (on the TV) coming down the ladder now. (Pause)

    109:22:59 Armstrong: Okay. I just checked getting back up to that first step, Buzz. It’s…The strut isn’t collapsed too far, but it’s adequate to get back up.

    109:23:10 McCandless: Roger. We copy.
    109:23:11 Armstrong: Takes a pretty good little jump.

    The same thing happened on Apollo 12, and Charles Conrad, being a bit shorter than Neil Armstrong, burst out with the following first words on the moon… a bit less well known for their gravitas:

    "Whoopee! Man, that may have been a small step for Neil, but that’s a long one for me."

  8. While researching the Apollo 11 Goodwill Disc, I found this Armstrong quote from a 2001 interview at JSC, an inspiring message for the new generation of approaches to detecting and defending planet Earth from asteroids:

    "it’s so small, it’s very colorful — you know, you see an ocean and gaseous layer, a little bit, just a tiny bit, of atmosphere around it. And, compared with all the other celestial objects — which, in many cases, are much more massive, more terrifying — it looks like it couldn’t put up a very good defense against a celestial onslaught."

    When I visited Meteor Crater with Apollo 9 astronaut and B612 founder Rusty Schweickart, we found a series of vintage Apollo photos of their training at that very site almost 50 years ago.

    Hiking Meteor Crater with Rusty Schweickart of Apollo 9

  9. When I read about Apollo, I often think about all of the sims that Michael Collins and the other command module pilots must have run, to make sure they were well-practiced on piloting the CSM back to earth solo.

  10. Great story, the business of the lever and the nightmares makes it all seem real (there are still people that think it was all rigged on a Hollywood sound stage). Seriously this is the best moon landing story I have ever heard.

  11. He is one of the few human beings we aliens happen to converse about with sheer interest and quite an admiration. Glad you had the honor of meeting him. Happy Birthday, Neil Armstrong.

  12. And in this new video share by David Hoffman, Gene Cernan shares how it was a common worry to anticipate a failure to launch from the lunar surface.

Leave a Reply to jurvetson Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *