Canon EOS 5D Mark II
ƒ/6.3
300 mm
1/200
1600

Hanging by its tail from the balcony roof. (best viewed large)

Costa Rica: Abolished its army to invest in education instead. Almost a carbon neutral country, as all of their electricity comes from hydro, wind and geothermal, and they planted 3 million trees last year. The forest coverage grew from 21% in 1987 to 52% today. They made a bet that ecotourism would be a better use of the land than cattle farming. And now it does earn more than cattle, bananas and coffee combined. And they are still the second largest banana producer in the world.

I was reading these stats in Stewart Brand’s new book, Whole Earth Discipline, while ensconced in the Guanacaste Forest he celebrates.

And how about the Costa Ricans?
They are the happiest people on Earth (NYT).

Here are some provocative quotes from Stewart Brand’s book – a eco-friendly pragmatist’s celebration of urbanization, nuclear energy and genetically modified organisms:

“Climate change. Urbanization. Biotechnology. Those three narratives, still taking shape, are developing a long arc likely to dominate this century.

In all societies from hunter-gatherers on up through agricultural tribes, then chiefdoms, to early complex civilizations, 25 percent of adult males routinely died from warfare… Humans perpetually fight because they always outstrip the carrying capacity of their natural environment and then have to fight over resources… Peace can break out, though, when carrying capacity is pushed up suddenly, as with the invention of agriculture…trade, or technological breakthroughs. Also a large-scale dieback from pestilence can make for peaceful times… With climate change under way… we face a carrying capacity crisis leading to war of all against all, this time with massively lethal weapons and a dieback measured in billions.

The United States and France have the highest birth rates in the developed world, just below replacement level. America does it with immigrants and churchgoers… France does it with socialism.

Fully 85 percent of the world’s working age youth, those between the ages of 15 and 24, live in the developing world.

Chernobyl: The real damage to people in the region is from poverty and mental stress. Fear of radiation is a far more important health threat than radiation itself. The zone’s evacuation put an end to industrialization, deforestation, cultivation and other human intrusions, making it one of Ukraine’s environmentally cleanest regions… The world’s worst nuclear power plant disaster is not as destructive to wildlife populations as are normal human activities. Even where the levels of radiation are highest, wildlife abounds. I predict there will be a Chernobyl National Park.

Nuclear energy has done more to eliminate existing nuclear weapons from the world than any other activity. …currently 10% of the electricity Americans use comes from Russian missiles and bombs.

Coal is now understood to be the long-term systemic horror we once thought nuclear was.

The environmental movement has done more harm with its opposition to genetic engineering than with any other thing we have been wrong about. We’ve starved people, hindered science, hurt the natural environment, and denied our own practitioners a crucial tool. We make ourselves look a conspicuously irrational as those who espouse ‘intelligent design’ or ban stem-cell research, and we teach that irrationality to the public and to decision makers.

As with nuclear, those who know the most are the least frightened.

By current estimates, 80% of the genes in microbes traveled horizontally at some point in their past. Parasitic plants and fungi swap genes spontaneously with their hosts. Virus-like genes represent a staggering 90% of the human genome.

Despite their best efforts to shut it down or ignore it, environmentalists gained more from the space program than anyone else, and sooner.

Ecosystem engineering is an ancient art, practiced and malpracticed by every human society since the mastery of fire.

A continental American population estimated to have been between 50 million and 100 million in 1491 was reduced to 6.5 million by 1650. It was the greatest cataclysm in human history; a fifth of the world’s population died. We think of it as a military event, but it was almost entirely biological.

China, a nation run by engineers rather than lawyers.

When Kevin Kelly was traveling in China in 2006, he found that every elementary school in every village had a sign over the door in Mandarin with the following guidance:

LOOK UP TO SCIENCE.
CARE FOR YOUR FAMILY.
RESPECT LIFE.
RESIST CULTY RELIGION.”

14 responses to “Mission Impossible — Whole Earth Discipline in Costa Rica”

  1. Steve, I’m going to tell as many people as I can to read this.

    Seen on my Flickr home page. (?)

  2. "And how about the Costa Ricans?
    They are the happiest people on Earth "

    Costa Rica is also, possibly, the nicest place on earth. The one place i have visited and thought "damn, I want to live here"

  3. The reindeer, that are the basis of the economy of the Same (Lapplanders) people in northern Scandinavia, have still not recovered from the radioactive "hot spots" dumped on northern Sweden and Norway by the Chernobyl accident.

    http://www.utexas.edu/courses/sami/dieda/socio/chernobyl.htm

    Otherwise, good article and I agree with most points.

  4. A darling little creature 🙂

  5. Steve, you have awesome shots and great commentary, but I wonder where Stewart Brand got his birthrate figures from. According to en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_birth_rate the USA is #139 and France #152 in the world. The list of developed countries en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Developed_country includes Brunei (#87), Israel (#99), Kuwait (#117), Quatar (#127), UAE (#128), Ireland (#129), Iceland (#137) before USA, and furthermore New Zealand (#140), Australia (#149) and Cyprus (#151) before France.

  6. Those are total birth rates. Brand was referring to sub-replacement fertility. This is the critical demographic measure of whether a population is growing or shrinking geometrically over time (with the threshold of 2.1 children per woman, given early mortality rates).

    The big picture, is that most of the developed world is facing a difficult demographic destiny (blue countries are sub-replacement), from wikipedia:

    You can see reference to the U.S. and France at this wikipedia page

    Lilly Hunter: Small world. Those Sami reindeer herders are my peeps! And if I am skimming the article right, the Sami killed less reindeer because of confusion and fear of radioactivity. This hurt them economically. But, they did not find evidence of health harm. So even though that article was written with a tone of concern, it seems to support all of Brand’s arguments: that fear of radiation is worse than radiation itself, and ironically, such fears help to protect animals from slaughter!

    Summary of Brand’s argument on nuclear: the argument that a bit more radioactivity is good for you is one fringe argument. Some parts of the world have background radiation 1000x the EPA regulated level for power plants, and the people living there are doing just fine. So it’s a question of degree. An absolutist stance that any radiation is unacceptable, during generation or storage, is illogical in an context of tradeoffs. For Chernobyl, there are tradeoffs. Some deleterious effects downwind were outweighed by the environmental benefits from simply halting routine human activity in the region (per the conclusion of the UN aftermath study). Puts things in perspective. And if you compare to the reigning alternative for generating that electricity — coal — then there is no contest. Coal’s environmental and health risks are greater, global and long term. France has the cleanest air in Europe, versus China, where the annual deaths are staggering. This is why scientists who dispassionately look at the data anew, with consistent logical frameworks across the alternatives, end up shifting pro-nuclear.

  7. I had the pleasure of hearing Stewart Brand discuss his book in NYC a few months ago. His arguments on nuclear are of course provocative to many, but to me the book’s central point is that if we are to solve our massive problems, it’s essential to keep our minds open to "heretical" views.

    In that context, his mention of Kevin Kelly’s "Resist Culty Religion" observation got a good response from the audience.

    If you haven’t already, take a look at http://www.sbnotes.com, his annotated bibliography/companion to the book. Online, he explores the controversial hormesis hypothesis (some radiation is good for you) in more detail.

    For anyone interested in more detail, the Long Now Foundation has one of his talks online here [41MB MP3].

    (Oh, and the photo is beautiful too, of course.)

  8. Exept for the fact he is hanging by his tail (I would not dare to try to do that) he looks just like me (in my best days). Nice picture Steve.

    denis

  9. heh… thanks!

    and thank for the links complexify!

    Magical sight, even stepping back,,,

    Four Season Papagayo

  10. great read, awesome monkey

    The World Through My Eyes

  11. Anywhere outside of mainland USA might seem almost ‘socialist’ in such major abstracted, capitalist ‘social entrepeneurial’ company?USA though is too much an apologist for biotech’ or gmos or the human genome project (eg the Celera company keeping patents) so others cant do research easily without costing the earth.

    Costa Rica does sound visionary if we are to accept or believe the first paragraph fully.Perhaps USA could take a leaf from its book re ecotourism and such like?

  12. One of the questions that pops up is: How does the author measure survivors?

    Measuring points:
    1) Right after the accident at Chernobyl;
    vs.
    2) Several years after the accident–when one can argue that whatever species is measured has learned to live with increased levels of radiation.

    In other words, who wants to be first/nearest to the blast?

  13. Yep, definitely stepping this back sight is magical :)- I mean what I say.

Leave a Reply to solerena Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *